Wednesday, September 18, 2019
Compare the theme of seduction in To his coy mistress and The Essay exa
Compare the theme of seduction in To his coy mistress and The  seduction    The poem ââ¬Å"to his coy mistressâ⬠ was written by Andrew Marvell between  1621 and 1678. However ââ¬Å"The seductionâ⬠ (which was written by Eileen  McAuley-a woman) was written much later, in the 1980ââ¬â¢s. Both poems are  about a man trying to persuade a woman to sleep with him. In ââ¬Å"THCMâ⬠  the man uses flattery and persuasion ââ¬Å"For lady you deserve this  state.â⬠ In this poem however we never actually discover if he was  successful in persuading her. In ââ¬Å"The seductionâ⬠ he seduces her using  alcohol in the hope that she will sleep with him if she is drunk. In  this poem we do discover that he is successful as the girl becomes  pregnant.    In ââ¬Å"THCMâ⬠ the male is narrating for example ââ¬Å"ourâ⬠ and ââ¬Å"we.â⬠ In ââ¬Å"The  seductionâ⬠ neither of the characters narrates. It is written in third  person ââ¬Å"He lead her to the quite bricks of Birkenhead docks.â⬠  Throughout the entire poem no names are used ââ¬Å"heâ⬠ and ââ¬Å"she.â⬠ I think  this symbolises that the situation is quite common. In both poems our  sympathies are with the women. We sympathise with the women in ââ¬Å"The  seductionâ⬠ because she becomes pregnant and truly regrets her actions  ââ¬Å"So she cried that she had missed all the innocence around her.â⬠ In  ââ¬Å"THCMâ⬠ our sympathy is also with the woman as she is being pressurised  into to having sex even though she might not want to.    The men in both poems are similar in one way as they are both seducing  the woman in the hope that she will sleep with them. However they both  act very different. The man in ââ¬Å"THCMâ⬠ is more romantic as he takes the  time to admire and appreciate the woman ââ¬Å"An hundred years should go to  praise Thine eyes, and on thy forehead gaze.â⬠ Whereas in ââ¬Å"The  seductionâ⬠ He doe...              ...of nicotine.â⬠ I think this definitely comes across during the  poems, and is a clear difference.    In conclusion it is clear that both are poems are about a man seducing  a woman in the hope that she will sleep with him. I believe the  biggest difference between the poems is to do with the date when they  were written. Both time eras had completely different attitudes to  sex, which is why the men go about a different way to seduce the women  The poem that I find more persuasive and effective is ââ¬Å"THCMâ⬠ because  the man actually loved the lady â⬠I would love you ten years before the  floodâ⬠ and his intentions were slightly more pure it seems, compared  to the man in ââ¬Å"the seductionâ⬠ who simply took advantage of the woman  and didnââ¬â¢t care for her one bit. I also think that it is very cleverly  written and is interesting how each stanza represents a different time  frame.                      
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
 
 
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.